Chessy
Benoni Defense: Old Benoni, Schmid Variation – Playing for a Win with Black
The Old Benoni is a sharp choice for Black, and the Schmid Variation (1.d4 c5 2.d5 d6 3.Nc3 g6) is its most aggressive branch. You immediately fianchetto your king's bishop, challenging White's centre from the long diagonal. The engine gives this position +0.85 — a clear edge for White — but the results from real games tell a different story: across over 15,000 games Black actually wins 49.7% of the time, slightly outscoring White. That gap between evaluation and results is exactly why this opening is so rewarding to learn. The drill below will help you navigate White's most common setups and turn your practical chances into full points.
Play the Benoni Defense: Old Benoni, Schmid Variation against the engine
Free, no signup — you play black, the engine adapts to your level.
Jump into the interactive drill below and practise the Schmid Variation against White's most common replies. It's free — no account needed to start playing.
Create a free account →Why the Schmid Variation Works on the Board
The engine may say White is better, but Black's winning percentage at 49.7% (against White's 46.9%, with only 3.4% draws) shows this is no passive defence. After 3...g6 you are preparing to meet most White moves with ...Bg7, pressuring the d4-pawn and the dark squares. This is an unbalanced, fighting position from move three — ideal if you want active piece play rather than quiet equality. Your king finds safety quickly behind the fianchetto, while White often spends a tempo deciding whether to close the centre with e4 or develop more cautiously. In practice, White's extra space rarely translates into an easy attack, while your counterplay against d5 and later on the queenside or in the centre keeps the game tense for both sides.
The Critical Moment: Picking Your Reply to White's Best Move
Stockfish recommends Nf3 as White's strongest continuation, planning e4 next to build a broad pawn centre. Nf3 appears in 2,183 games from this position, and White scores just 46.6% — meaning Black is doing fine. The engine line runs Nf3 Bg7 e4 Nf6, a natural sequence where you develop your kingside pieces, keep an eye on e4, and prepare to challenge the centre with ...d5 or ...b5 later. Don't fear White's central pawns; your g7-bishop already eyes the d4-square, and your knight on f6 can later hop to d7 or join a queenside expansion. The key is not to rush — finish your development and let White's extra space become a weakness.
White's Most Popular Moves – What the Stats Reveal
While Nf3 is the engine's top choice, human players overwhelmingly prefer e4 — it appears in 8,971 games, more than the other four options combined. That's good news for you: White scores only 47.3% after e4, almost identical to the Nf3 line. Your plan is the same: develop your bishop to g7, bring out your knight to f6, and castle quickly. After e4, Black has scored very well by keeping the position closed and waiting for White to overextend. The other common tries — Bf4 (1,763 games, 46.7% for White), Bg5 (876 games, 46.8%), e3 (276 games, 45.7%), and g3 (216 games, 45.8%) — all give Black excellent results too. White's winning percentage never cracks 48% against the Schmid, which is a striking endorsement of this setup.
A Practical Repertoire Tip for the Schmid
This variation suits players who enjoy one-move-ahead thinking: you know you will fianchetto on g7, and your opponent's move rarely changes that plan. Against e4 you play ...Bg7 and ...Nf6; against Nf3 you do the same; against early bishop moves like Bf4 or Bg5 you develop naturally and can often gain time by attacking the bishop. Because the Schmid avoids the most heavily analysed Benoni lines (where ...e6 or ...Nf6 are played early), you stay in a zone where general principles matter more than deep memorisation. Just remember: your king belongs on g8, your knight on f6, and your long-term breaks are ...b5 and ...e6. Play the drill a few times and you'll see how smoothly Black's position handles White's different approaches.
Results across 15,234 Lichess games
| Most-played continuation | Games | White wins |
|---|---|---|
| e4 | 8,971 | 47.3% |
| Nf3 | 2,183 | 46.6% |
| Bf4 | 1,763 | 46.7% |
| Bg5 | 876 | 46.8% |
| e3 | 276 | 45.7% |
| g3 | 216 | 45.8% |
Frequently asked questions
Is the Old Benoni, Schmid Variation good for beginners?
Yes — the plan is simple and consistent: fianchetto your king's bishop, develop your knight to f6, and castle. You don't need to memorise long forcing lines, and the statistics show Black scores very well in practice even if the engine prefers White. It's a great way to learn counterplay and unbalanced positions.
What is the best move for White against the Schmid Variation?
According to Stockfish, the best move is Nf3, preparing e4 to build a big centre. But White scores only 46.6% after Nf3, so Black has nothing to fear. The most common move in practice is e4, where White also scores below 50%. Either way, your setup with ...Bg7 and ...Nf6 works well.
How do I avoid losing quickly as Black in the Schmid?
Just develop naturally: ...Bg7, ...Nf6, castle kingside, and don't grab material too early. White has more space but no direct threats. The engine evaluation of +0.85 means White is slightly better, but the real-game results (49.7% Black wins) show that White's theoretical edge rarely turns into a win without mistakes from Black. Stay solid and you'll outplay them.
What are White's weakest moves after 3...g6?
The stats show e3 and g3 give White their lowest scores — 45.7% and 45.8% respectively. Both are less ambitious than e4 or Nf3, and Black can equalise easily by following the same development scheme. If White plays e3, you can even consider ...d5 immediately, locking the centre on favourable terms.