Chessy
Indian Defense: Anti-Nimzo-Indian: d5 — A Comfortable Edge for White
If you play 1.d4, you know Black often tries to steer the game into sharp Nimzo-Indian waters. The Anti-Nimzo-Indian with 3.Nf3 and 4.Nc3 keeps the position solid while preserving a small but persistent pull. With +0.28 from the engine, you are slightly better — and across over 7 million games, White scores 51.9%, with Black winning only 43.8%. The position is still early, but you already have a clear direction. Let's see what the statistics and the engine recommend, and how you can punish Black's most common mistakes.
Play the Indian Defense: Anti-Nimzo-Indian: d5 against the engine
Free, no signup — you play white, the engine adapts to your level.
Ready to put these ideas into practice? Jump into the interactive drill below — you play White against an adapting engine that learns from your mistakes. Create
Create a free account →The Position After 4.Nc3 — What Are You Fighting For?
After 1.d4 Nf6 2.c4 e6 3.Nf3 d5 4.Nc3, Black hasn't committed to pinning your knight on c3 yet. The engine's assessment of +0.28 reflects White's natural spatial advantage in the centre. You have two central pawns (d4 and c4) facing Black's d5 pawn, and your knights are already developed to active squares. The key struggle here is the centre: Black wants to undermine your pawn duo with moves like ...c5 or ...dxc4, while you want to maintain tension or find the right moment to clarify. The good news is that White's results are healthy — you win 51.9% of games from here, and the draw rate is low at 4.2%, which means you can play for a win without excessive risk.
The Engine's Top Move: 5.c5
Stockfish recommends a move that may look surprising at first: 5.c5. The engine's continuation runs 5.c5 cxd5 6.cxd4 7.Qxd4. By advancing your c-pawn to c5, you grab space on the queenside and fix Black's d5 pawn as a potential target. The trade that follows leads to a queen exchange, simplifying into a middlegame where your spatial advantage and bishop pair (if Black trades knights) can matter. While 5.c5 is not the most popular choice in practice (it has been played 1,072,548 times), it scores 48.8% for White — respectable — and the engine believes it's the most principled path. That said, many of the most-played alternatives score even better, which brings us to the next section.
What Black Plays Most — And How You Should Answer
Here are the top replies you'll face, and what the statistics tell you about each one. The percentages are White's combined score (wins + half of draws): Bb4 (2,497,253 games – 53.9% for White). This is by far Black's most common move — the Nimzo-Indian pin still on offer. If you know your Nimzo-Indian lines, you'll be fine, but even without deep preparation, White scores well. Be7 (1,125,960 games – 49.0%). A quieter, more passive setup. Black develops but gives you time. c5 (1,072,548 games – 48.8%). The engine's suggestion for Black, leading to the 5.c5 line discussed above. c6 (576,589 games – 50.2%). The Slav-style setup, holding d5. You have a slight edge. Nc6 (470,966 games – 55.6% for White). This is a tactical mistake you can punish — see below. dxc4 (368,140 games – 55.4% for White). Black surrenders the centre early, and White scores well.
Punishing Black's Biggest Blunders
Two of Black's most-played continuations give you excellent winning chances. Let's highlight them. 5...Nc6 (470,966 games, White scores 55.6%). Black develops the knight to a natural square but ignores the tension in the centre. You can take advantage by capturing on d5 or playing a quick e3-e4 to seize even more space. With White scoring over 55%, this is one of those moments where a generic developing move costs Black dearly. 5...dxc4 (368,140 games, White scores 55.4%). Black captures your c-pawn, but this is rarely correct when you haven't committed to defending it. You can recapture with the bishop on e3 or with the knight after a preparatory move, and your centre remains strong while Black struggles to hold the extra pawn. Both of these moves show that Black needs precision from move 5 — and many club players don't have it.
Results across 7,121,164 Lichess games
| Most-played continuation | Games | White wins |
|---|---|---|
| Bb4 | 2,497,253 | 53.9% |
| Be7 | 1,125,960 | 49.0% |
| c5 | 1,072,548 | 48.8% |
| c6 | 576,589 | 50.2% |
| Nc6 | 470,966 | 55.6% |
| dxc4 | 368,140 | 55.4% |
Frequently asked questions
Is the Anti-Nimzo-Indian d5 a good opening for beginners?
Yes. The Anti-Nimzo-Indian d5 is a straightforward way to avoid sharp Nimzo-Indian theory while keeping a solid plus for White. The engine gives +0.28, a small edge for White, meaning you are slightly better without needing to memorise deep lines. The positions are strategic and intuitive, ideal for club players.
What is the most common mistake Black makes in this opening?
Black's most punishable mistake is probably 5...Nc6, which has been played almost 471,000 times and gives White a 55.6% score. It ignores the central tension and allows White to take the initiative. Another common error is 5...dxc4, which surrenders the centre and gives White a 55.4% score.
Should I play 5.c5 as White?
According to Stockfish at depth 16, 5.c5 is the engine's best move. It grabs space and leads to a simplified middlegame with a comfortable edge. However, many players prefer other developing moves, which also score well. The statistics show 5.c5 scores 48.8% — solid, but not the highest-scoring option for White.
Why does Black play 4...Bb4 so often?
4...Bb4 is the most popular move by a wide margin (2,497,253 games) because it transposes into the Nimzo-Indian Defense. Many Black players are comfortable there. White scores 53.9% from this position, so you should be happy to see it — just be ready to play a standard Nimzo-Indian line as White.
How many games feature the Indian Defense: Anti-Nimzo-Indian: d5?
Over 7 million Lichess games have reached the Indian Defense: Anti-Nimzo-Indian: d5 position. White wins 51.9%, Black wins 43.8%, with 4.2% draws — based on real rated games.