Chessy
How to Play Against the Italian Game: d6
After 1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6, many Italian Game players choose 3.Bc4. Your reply — 3…d6 — signals a solid, classical approach, but now you face an immediate test: White pushes 4.d4, striking at the centre. The engine rates this position +0.54, a small edge for White, and the database backs that up — White wins 53.0% of games here, while you win 43.0% (4.0% are drawn). This page walks you through the critical moment and the one move you need to play to stay in the game.
Practice playing against the Italian Game: d6
Free, no signup — you play black, the engine adapts to your level.
Now it's your turn. Play the position as Black against a live engine and practise finding 4…exd4 every time. Start the drill — it's free.
Create a free account →The Central Showdown: 4.d4
White's 4.d4 is the most direct challenge to your set-up. By playing 3…d6 you've guarded the e5 pawn, but now White tries to break it open anyway. The pawn on d4 attacks your e5 pawn — you have to decide how to respond. The statistics across 3,031,488 games show that this position is a fork in the road: many players pick tempting alternatives, but only one move keeps Black's position balanced. Your task is to understand why 4.d4 is a test, and why the right answer is the one your opponent least wants you to find.
The Only Good Move: exd4
The engine's top move — and the one you should play — is exd4. After 4…exd4 5.Nxd4, the line continues 5…Be7 and then 6.O-O, leading to a normal, playable game. This is the path of least regret: you give back the centre pawn temporarily, complete development, and castle quickly. The numbers back it up: exd4 has been played 1,170,717 times, and White scores only 51.6% — the lowest winning percentage for White among all major replies. That's your best chance to fight for a full share of the game.
Three Moves That Punish Themselves
The database reveals that several common moves are outright mistakes. Avoid them, especially if you see them recommended elsewhere online. Bg4 (784,838 games) is an inaccuracy that loses about 0.8 pawns of advantage — White scores 50.0%, which sounds OK, but the engine says you are already worse. h6 (230,614 games) is another inaccuracy, losing about 0.5 pawns (White scores 54.0%). The worst offender is Be6 (144,863 games): a blunder costing roughly 3.4 pawns. White scores a crushing 68.8% from that position. In each case the correct move is the same: exd4.
The Italian Game: d6 Suits You If…
This opening is a fine choice if you prefer solid, classical chess without early tactical fireworks. You're not trying to refute White; you're aiming to reach a middlegame where your central pawn structure is sound and your pieces develop naturally. The line after 4…exd4 5.Nxd4 Be7 6.O-O leads to a position where both sides have healthy prospects. Just remember: the moment White plays 4.d4, your only reliable answer is to capture. Steer clear of Bg4, h6, and especially Be6, and you'll avoid most of the pain that catches unprepared Black players.
Results across 3,031,488 Lichess games
| Most-played continuation | Games | White wins |
|---|---|---|
| exd4 | 1,170,717 | 51.6% |
| Bg4 | 784,838 | 50.0% |
| h6 | 230,614 | 54.0% |
| Nf6 | 214,891 | 56.8% |
| Be6 | 144,863 | 68.8% |
| Nxd4 | 125,834 | 53.7% |
Frequently asked questions
Is the Italian Game: d6 a good opening for Black?
It is a solid, classical choice, but be honest about the verdict: the engine gives White a small edge (+0.54). Black scores 43.0% across millions of games (with 53.0% White wins and 4.0% draws). If you play accurately — starting with 4…exd4 — you can equalise comfortably, but you are fighting for equality as Black.
Why is 4…exd4 the best move after 4.d4 in the Italian Game: d6?
The engine recommends 4…exd4 because it keeps your position the most solid. After 5.Nxd4 Be7 6.O-O, Black finishes development and gets ready to castle. The statistics confirm this: White scores only 51.6% after exd4 — the lowest winning percentage of any reply. Other moves let White build a bigger advantage.
Is 4…Bg4 a mistake in the Italian Game: d6?
Yes, 4…Bg4 is an inaccuracy. It's played often (784,838 games), but the engine says it loses about 0.8 pawns of advantage. White scores 50.0% from that position, which is worse for you than it looks — the engine verdict makes clear you are already worse. The better move is 4…exd4.
Why is 4…Be6 so bad in this position?
4…Be6 is a blunder, costing roughly 3.4 pawns. White scores an overwhelming 68.8% after that move. The idea of trading the light-squared bishops is understandable, but White's lead in development becomes crushing. Never play 4…Be6 here; always capture with exd4 instead.
How many games feature the Italian Game: d6?
Over 3 million Lichess games have reached the Italian Game: d6 position. White wins 53.0%, Black wins 43.0%, with 4.0% draws — based on real rated games.
What is Stockfish's evaluation of the Italian Game: d6?
At depth 16, Stockfish rates the Italian Game: d6 as a slight advantage for White (+0.54) from White's perspective. This is the computer's assessment of the position after the main opening moves.